• Check out these discounted items on TikTok

Reminder: Tolkien hated Disney.

He called them "hopelessly corrupted" and knew they'd ruin any story they touched.

Why? Tolkien's storytelling philosophy was profoundly different… (thread)

Tolkien’s Disdain for Disney: A Clash of Storytelling Philosophies

J.R.R. Tolkien, the revered author of "The Lord of the Rings" and "The Hobbit," is often celebrated for his rich, immersive storytelling and deep world-building. However, he held a strong aversion to Disney, famously labeling the company as "hopelessly corrupted." This sentiment stems from a fundamental difference in storytelling philosophies between Tolkien and Disney, which has significant implications for how narratives are crafted and perceived.

Tolkien’s Perspective on Storytelling

At the heart of Tolkien’s storytelling is a profound respect for the integrity of myth and legend. He believed that stories should serve a greater purpose, often reflecting deep moral truths and exploring the complexities of human experience. For Tolkien, narratives were not merely entertainment; they were vehicles for conveying wisdom, values, and the intricate nature of existence. His works are steeped in lore, drawing from various mythologies and languages to create a sense of authenticity and depth.

In contrast, Disney’s approach focuses on accessibility and mass appeal. The company is known for its ability to transform complex narratives into simplified, family-friendly versions that often prioritize entertainment over substance. This commercial model can dilute the richness of the original stories, stripping away their nuanced themes and character complexities. Tolkien feared that such adaptations would ultimately undermine the core messages of the tales he held dear.

The Dangers of Simplification

Tolkien’s wariness of Disney reflects concerns about the oversimplification of narratives. He believed that reducing a story to fit commercial interests could lead to the loss of its original meaning and emotional impact. When stories are altered to cater to a broader audience, they can lose the depth that makes them resonate with readers on a profound level. This is particularly relevant in the context of adaptations, where the essence of the source material can be compromised for the sake of entertainment value.

Tolkien’s own works exemplify the intricate layers of storytelling that he cherished. From the rich histories of Middle-earth to the moral dilemmas faced by his characters, Tolkien’s narratives invite readers to explore complex themes such as heroism, sacrifice, and the struggle between good and evil. This depth is often absent in adaptations that prioritize visual spectacle over thematic exploration.

The Importance of Authenticity

For Tolkien, authenticity in storytelling was paramount. He believed that a story should remain true to its roots, honoring the cultural and historical contexts from which it emerges. This authenticity fosters a deeper connection between the narrative and its audience, allowing readers to engage with the material on multiple levels. Disney’s tendency to prioritize commercial success can overshadow this authenticity, leading to adaptations that may not do justice to the original works.

Conclusion

Tolkien’s disdain for Disney serves as a reminder of the intricate relationship between storytelling and its adaptation. While both Tolkien and Disney have made indelible marks on the literary and cinematic landscapes, their philosophies diverge significantly. As audiences, it is essential to recognize and appreciate the depth of storytelling that Tolkien championed, while also being mindful of the potential pitfalls of oversimplifying narratives for mass consumption. In a world where stories are constantly being reimagined, understanding these differences can help preserve the integrity of the tales we hold dear.

Reminder: Tolkien hated Disney.

He called them “hopelessly corrupted” and knew they’d ruin any story they touched.

Why? Tolkien’s storytelling philosophy was profoundly different… (thread) pic.twitter.com/bx73vzKKpk

— The Culturist (@the_culturist_) March 28, 2025

Reminder: Tolkien Hated Disney

Isn’t it fascinating how two different worlds of storytelling can clash so dramatically? When we think of the enchanting realms created by J.R.R. Tolkien and the whimsical magic of Disney, one might assume they could coexist harmoniously. However, Tolkien had a very different perspective. He famously expressed disdain for Disney, labeling them as “hopelessly corrupted.” This sentiment raises an intriguing question: why did the mastermind behind Middle-earth have such strong feelings against the iconic animation studio?

He Called Them “Hopelessly Corrupted”

Tolkien’s disdain for Disney wasn’t just a passing comment; it was deeply rooted in his beliefs about storytelling and its purpose. He believed that the essence of a story could be corrupted by commercial interests, and Disney epitomized that risk. When you think about it, Tolkien dedicated his life to crafting intricate worlds filled with rich lore and profound themes. He viewed storytelling as a sacred act that transcended mere entertainment, while Disney’s approach often leaned towards mass appeal and commercial success.

In his view, when you prioritize profit over authenticity, the soul of the story is lost. This philosophy is beautifully detailed in a [Twitter thread](https://twitter.com/the_culturist_/status/1905688396162596914?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw) where discussions about Tolkien’s views reveal his belief that great storytelling should evoke deep emotions, provoke thought, and inspire readers. Unfortunately, he felt that Disney’s approach could dilute these essential elements.

And Knew They’d Ruin Any Story They Touched

Imagine Tolkien’s reaction if he had been around during the early Disney adaptations of classic fairy tales. You can almost hear him sighing in frustration as beloved stories were transformed into light-hearted musicals and comedic animations. For Tolkien, the integrity of a story was paramount. He understood that every character, every plot twist, and every setting held a deeper meaning.

This brings us to the heart of the matter: storytelling is about more than just entertainment; it’s about connection. When a story is altered for the sake of mass consumption, the original connection that the author intended to create can be lost. In Tolkien’s eyes, this was a tragedy. He believed that true storytelling should challenge the audience, encouraging them to reflect on their own lives and choices.

Why? Tolkien’s Storytelling Philosophy Was Profoundly Different

So, what was it about Tolkien’s storytelling philosophy that set him apart? For starters, he was a master of world-building. His works, such as *The Hobbit* and *The Lord of the Rings*, are not just stories; they are entire universes filled with languages, cultures, and histories. Each character is meticulously crafted, with motivations and arcs that resonate with readers on multiple levels.

In contrast, Disney often favors charming characters and catchy songs over complex narratives. While there’s nothing inherently wrong with that approach, Tolkien believed that such simplicity could lead to a superficial understanding of the story. He sought to create layers of meaning, inviting readers to dive deep into the themes of courage, friendship, and sacrifice.

Tolkien’s insistence on the importance of mythology and tradition also sets him apart from Disney’s often modernized retellings. He believed that stories should reflect the human experience, drawing from ancient myths and legends to convey universal truths. Disney, on the other hand, frequently opts for contemporary interpretations, which can sometimes miss the mark when it comes to the depth and richness of the original tales.

The Impact of Tolkien’s Views Today

Fast forward to the present day, and it’s clear that Tolkien’s concerns about storytelling remain relevant. With the rise of franchises and adaptations, many fans find themselves craving the authenticity and depth that Tolkien championed. Adaptations of beloved stories often spark debates about fidelity to the source material, with many echoing Tolkien’s worries about commercialization overshadowing the original narrative.

Moreover, as audiences become more discerning, there’s a growing demand for stories that resonate on a deeper level. People are seeking narratives that challenge them, provoke thought, and inspire meaningful discussions. This shift can be seen in the popularity of shows and films that prioritize character development and complex themes.

Final Thoughts on Tolkien’s Legacy

Ultimately, J.R.R. Tolkien’s perspective on storytelling serves as a reminder of the power that narratives hold. They shape our understanding of the world and reflect our values and beliefs. While Disney has undoubtedly created a legacy of its own, one can’t help but wonder what Tolkien would think of today’s adaptations and storytelling trends.

In a landscape filled with endless content, perhaps we would all benefit from revisiting Tolkien’s philosophy. His belief in the sanctity of storytelling reminds us that, at its core, a good story is about connection, authenticity, and depth. So the next time you indulge in a fantastical tale, take a moment to consider what it truly means and how it reflects the world around us.