[Active shooter drills] trigger anxiety, stress, and fear in students, claims TN Students Demand Action leader

Title: Active Shooter Drills: A Necessary Evil or a Source of Anxiety?

Introduction

Active shooter drills have become a common practice in schools across the United States in response to the alarming rise in incidents of school shootings. While these drills aim to prepare students and staff for potential emergencies, some argue that they have unintended consequences. According to Ibti, a leader from Tennessee’s Students Demand Action group, these drills not only fail to prevent school shootings but also contribute to anxiety, stress, depression, and fear among students.

The Impact on Students

The testimonies of students who have undergone active shooter drills echo Ibti’s sentiments. Many students report feeling intense anxiety and fear during these drills. The loud noises, simulated gunshots, and chaos can be traumatizing, especially for those who have experienced previous trauma or have anxiety disorders. The drills disrupt the learning environment and can negatively impact students’ mental health, leading to increased stress, depression, and even thoughts of self-harm.

Lack of Evidence for Efficacy

Critics argue that despite the potential harm caused to students, there is no concrete evidence to suggest that these drills effectively prevent school shootings. The focus on rehearsing responses to an active shooter situation may detract from implementing comprehensive measures to address the root causes of violence in schools. Some experts believe that investing in mental health resources, improving school climate, and implementing effective gun control measures would be more impactful in preventing these tragic incidents.

Alternative Approaches

Instead of relying solely on active shooter drills, educators and policymakers should consider alternative approaches that prioritize the well-being of students without compromising their safety. One such approach is the implementation of threat assessment teams, comprising mental health professionals, law enforcement, and school staff, who can identify and address potential threats before they escalate. This proactive approach could help create a safer environment while minimizing the psychological toll on students.

Supporting Student Mental Health

Recognizing the impact of these drills on student well-being, schools should also prioritize mental health support services. Increased funding for counselors and psychologists, as well as providing access to therapy and support groups, can help students cope with the anxiety and stress induced by these drills. By focusing on mental health resources, schools can create a supportive environment that helps students navigate their emotions and build resilience.

Balancing Preparedness and Psychological Well-being

Finding the right balance between preparedness and psychological well-being is crucial. Schools must reassess their current protocols and consider implementing drills that are less distressing for students, such as tabletop exercises or age-appropriate simulations. Clear communication with students and parents about the nature and purpose of these drills can help alleviate some of the anxiety associated with them.

Conclusion

While active shooter drills may have been implemented with good intentions, it is essential to acknowledge the negative impact they can have on students’ mental health. As Ibti and other students demand action, it becomes imperative for policymakers and educators to reevaluate current practices and explore alternative approaches to ensure the safety of students without causing unnecessary anxiety and fear. By prioritizing mental health resources and implementing proactive measures, schools can create a safer environment while supporting the psychological well-being of their students..

“[Active shooter drills] cause anxiety and make us feel like a school shooting is inevitable.” – Ibti, TN Students Demand Action leader

These drills don’t prevent school shootings, but they do cause anxiety, stress, depression, and fear in students. https://t.co/Ifogbv4X08

— Students Demand Action (@StudentsDemand) December 10, 2023

https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Source

@StudentsDemand said “[Active shooter drills] cause anxiety and make us feel like a school shooting is inevitable.” – Ibti, TN Students Demand Action leader These drills don’t prevent school shootings, but they do cause anxiety, stress, depression, and fear in students. youthtoday.org/2023/12/95-of-…

RELATED STORY.